Why Puppies Cry in Crates and How to Help Them Settle

Why Puppies Cry in Crates and How to Help Them Settle

Bringing a new puppy into your home is an exciting and joyous occasion, but it also comes with its fair share of challenges. One of the most crucial aspects of puppy training is crate training – teaching your new family member to view their crate as a safe and comfortable den. 

While crate training offers numerous benefits, such as aiding in toilet training and providing a secure, safe space for your puppy, it's not uncommon for new pet parents to encounter the common obstacle of puppy crying. The plaintive whimpers and mournful howls coming from the crate can be distressing, leaving new owners feeling uncertain about the process. 

However, with patience, understanding, and the right approach, you can help your puppy adjust to their crate, alleviate their anxiety, and transform their crate into a cherished retreat. In this article, we will delve into the reasons behind puppy crying during crate training and explore effective strategies to ease this transition to ensure a happy pup and happy owners.

Table of Contents

  • Why does my puppy cry in its crate?
  • Is it normal for a puppy to cry in its crate?
  • How can I stop my puppy from crying in its crate?
  • How long will it take for my puppy to stop crying in its crate?
  • Are there any specific breeds that are more prone to crate crying?
  • Should I let my puppy cry it out in the crate?
  • Can separation anxiety be a cause of crate crying in puppies?
  • What are some signs that my puppy's crate crying is due to fear or stress?
  • Are there any recommended toys or treats to help my puppy feel more comfortable in its crate?
  • Should I cover the crate to create a den-like environment?
  • Should I play music to soothe my puppy in their crate?
  • What is the best age to start crate training to prevent excessive crying?
  • Are there any alternative methods to crate training for a puppy that cries excessively?
  • What role does exercise and mental stimulation play in reducing crate crying?
  • Is it possible that my puppy's crate crying is due to a health issue?
  • Can I use calming aids or supplements to help my puppy settle in its crate?
  • How can I handle nighttime crate crying without disturbing my neighbors?
  • Why does my puppy cry in its crate?

    Puppies cry in their crate for various reasons, and understanding the cause can help address the issue and make crate training a more positive experience for your puppy. There are several common reasons why puppies cry in their crates:

    • Separation Anxiety: Puppies, especially when young, can experience separation anxiety when left alone in their crate. Remember, they have left the safety of their littermates and been thrust into a new environment. They may feel scared, lonely, or stressed when separated from their human family members.
    • Need for Attention: Puppies are social animals and crave interaction and attention. If your puppy cries in the crate, they might be seeking your attention and company.
    • Fear of Isolation: Being confined to a crate might trigger feelings of isolation or confinement in some puppies, leading to crying or whining.
    • Needing to Wee or Poo: Puppies have limited bladder and bowel control, and if they need to go to the toilet, they may cry to alert you that they need to be let out of the crate.
    • Unfamiliar Environment: If the crate is a new addition to your home, your puppy might need some time to adjust and become comfortable with it.
    • Hunger or Thirst: Puppies have small stomachs and need to eat frequently. If your puppy is hungry or thirsty, they may cry to let you know.
    • Unfamiliarity with Crate: If your puppy hasn't been properly crate trained, they may not understand that the crate is their safe and cosy den and may view it with fear.

    Is it normal for a puppy to cry in its crate?

    Yes, it is normal for a puppy to cry in its crate, especially during the initial stages of crate training. Crate training is a gradual process, and it's common for puppies to express their discomfort, anxiety, or uncertainty by whining, whimpering, or crying when confined to a crate.

    How can I stop my puppy from crying in its crate?

    Stopping a puppy from crying in its crate requires patience, consistency, and positive reinforcement. Crate training is a gradual process, and it's essential to address your puppy's concerns and make the crate a comfortable and inviting space. Here are some effective tips to help reduce crying and make crate time a positive experience for your puppy:

    • Positive Association: Create a positive association with the crate by offering treats, toys, or even feeding your puppy meals inside the crate (always under supervision). Encourage them to enter voluntarily and praise them when they do so.
    • Gradual Introduction: Introduce the crate slowly and in short intervals. Let your puppy explore the crate at their own pace without forcing them inside.
    • Short Duration: Start with short periods of crate time, gradually increasing the duration as your puppy becomes more comfortable. Avoid leaving them in the crate for extended periods, especially initially.
    • Calming Environment: Ensure the crate is placed in a quiet and calm area of your home. Avoid high-traffic areas or places with loud noises that may add to your puppy's anxiety.
    • Comfort Items: Provide your puppy with soft bedding and toys inside the crate. Familiar scents, such as a piece of clothing with your scent (or your breeder may give you a blanket with mother’s scent on it), can also provide comfort.
    • Scheduled Breaks: Give your puppy regular potty breaks and exercise outside the crate. This will help prevent accidents and reduce their anxiety.
    • Ignore Whining: Avoid giving in to your puppy's cries or letting them out of the crate when they whine. Wait for a brief moment of silence before opening the crate to avoid reinforcing the behaviour.
    • Calm Departures and Arrivals: When putting your puppy in the crate or letting them out, keep your actions calm and low-key. Avoid making a big fuss or showing excessive excitement, as this may exacerbate anxiety.
    • Desensitisation: Gradually increase the time your puppy spends in the crate, even if you are present in the room. This can help them feel more at ease when you need to leave them alone later.

    How long will it take for my puppy to stop crying in its crate?

    The time it takes for a puppy to stop crying in its crate can vary significantly from one puppy to another. The process of crate training and reducing crying depends on several factors, including your puppy's age, temperament, previous experiences, and how consistently you approach the training.

    For some puppies, it may only take a few days to a week to become comfortable with their crate and stop crying during crate time. Others may take a few weeks or even longer, especially if they have a more anxious or fearful disposition.

    Younger puppies may adjust to crate training more quickly, as they are generally more adaptable. Older puppies may take a bit more time to adapt to the new routine.

    If your puppy had negative experiences with confinement or if they were not crate trained before coming to your home, it may take longer to build positive associations with the crate.

    Are there any specific breeds that are more prone to crate crying?

    While there are no specific breeds that are universally prone to crate crying, certain individual dogs within any breed may be more likely to exhibit this behaviour. Crate crying can be influenced by a variety of factors, including the dog's temperament, previous experiences, socialisation, and training history.

    However, some breeds are generally more prone to experiencing separation anxiety, which can contribute to crate crying. Breeds that tend to form strong bonds with their owners and are more sensitive to being left alone may be more likely to exhibit separation anxiety and potentially cry in the crate. Examples of such breeds include:

    Labrador Retrievers: Labs are known for their friendly and social nature, and they can become very attached to their human family members.

    Golden Retrievers: Like Labs, Golden Retrievers are highly affectionate and can develop strong bonds with their owners.

    German Shepherds: German Shepherds are loyal and protective, and they may feel anxious when separated from their family.

    Cavalier King Charles Spaniels: Cavaliers are companion dogs that thrive on human interaction and may experience separation anxiety.

    Bichon Frises: Bichon Frises are affectionate lap dogs that can form close bonds with their owners.

    It's essential to understand that individual dogs' behaviour can vary widely within any breed, and there are always exceptions. Even within breeds that are generally more prone to separation anxiety, some dogs may adapt to crate training with ease, while others may take longer to feel comfortable in the crate.

    Should I let my puppy cry it out in the crate?

    Whether you should let your puppy cry it out in the crate is a matter of personal preference and training philosophy. Some dog owners and trainers believe in using the "cry it out" method, while others prefer a more gradual and gentle approach to crate training.

    The "cry it out" method involves allowing your puppy to cry or whine in the crate without offering immediate comfort or attention. The idea behind this approach is to teach the puppy to self-soothe and eventually learn that crying doesn't lead to getting out of the crate. Advocates of this method argue that it helps the puppy to adapt more quickly to crate training.

    However, it's important to consider the individual needs and temperament of your puppy. Some puppies may become highly distressed and anxious when left to cry without any comfort or attention. This can lead to increased stress and negative associations with the crate.

    Can separation anxiety be a cause of crate crying in puppies?

    Yes, separation anxiety can be a common cause of crate crying in puppies. Separation anxiety is a condition where dogs experience significant distress and anxiety when separated from their owners or left alone. It can manifest in various ways, including excessive vocalisation (whining, crying, barking), destructive behaviour, pacing, or attempting to escape from the confined area (such as a crate).

    When a puppy with separation anxiety is placed in a crate, the feeling of being confined or isolated can trigger their anxiety, leading to crying or vocalisation as they try to seek comfort or reassurance. The crate, which is intended to be a safe and comforting space, can become associated with fear and distress for a puppy experiencing separation anxiety.

    It's important to recognise the signs of separation anxiety in your puppy, as addressing this issue is crucial for their emotional well-being and training progress.

    What are some signs that my puppy's crate crying is due to fear or stress?

    If your puppy's crate crying is due to fear or stress, they may exhibit specific signs and behaviours that indicate their discomfort. Recognising these signs can help you understand your puppy's emotions and take appropriate steps to address their fears and reduce their stress. Some signs that your puppy's crate crying is related to fear or stress include:

    • Excessive Vocalisation: Your puppy may whine, whimper, bark, or howl excessively when placed in the crate. The vocalisation may be more intense and continuous compared to a puppy who is simply seeking attention or comfort.
    • Panting and Drooling: Anxious or stressed puppies may pant heavily, even when the environment is not warm, and they may drool more than usual.
    • Pacing and Restlessness: Your puppy may pace back and forth in the crate, unable to settle down or relax. They might appear agitated and unable to find a comfortable position.
    • Attempts to Escape: A stressed puppy may try to escape from the crate by pawing at the door, pushing against the sides, or chewing on the bars.
    • Destructive Behaviour: Stress and anxiety can lead to destructive behaviour, such as chewing on the crate or their bedding.
    • Hiding: Some puppies may attempt to hide or cower in the back of the crate, trying to avoid the perceived stressor.
    • Excessive Salivation: Stress and anxiety can cause increased salivation in some puppies, leading to wet spots or drool inside the crate.
    • Avoiding the Crate: A fearful puppy may resist going into the crate, trying to escape from it as soon as possible.

    If you observe these signs in your puppy, it's essential to approach crate training with extra care and patience. For puppies experiencing fear or stress in the crate, a gradual and positive reinforcement approach is crucial.

    Yes, there are several toys that can help your puppy feel more comfortable and relaxed in its crate during crate training. These items can create positive associations with the crate, making it a more enjoyable and inviting space for your furry friend. However, we don’t recommend leaving your puppy with long lasting treats or chews in their crate due to the potential choking hazard they pose.

    • Chew Toys: Chew toys can be a great way to keep your puppy entertained and provide mental stimulation while in the crate. Look for durable, puppy-safe chew toys made of materials like rubber or nylon.
    • Kong Toys: Kong toys are interactive treat-dispensing toys that can keep your puppy occupied and focused on getting the treats out. Stuff the Kong with your puppy's favourite small treats or some peanut butter to make crate time more enjoyable.
    • Interactive Puzzle Toys: Interactive puzzle toys challenge your puppy's problem-solving skills and can help alleviate boredom and anxiety. There are various types of puzzle toys available for puppies of different ages and skill levels.
    • Comforting Plush Toys: Soft, comforting plush toys can provide a sense of security for your puppy in the crate. Look for ones with different textures and sizes to appeal to your puppy's preferences.

    Should I cover the crate to create a den-like environment?

    Covering the crate to create a den-like environment can be a helpful strategy during crate training, especially for some puppies who may feel more secure and comfortable in a cosy, enclosed space. Dogs have an instinctive desire for a den-like environment, which makes covering the crate mimic the feeling of being in a safe and enclosed den. Here are some potential benefits of covering the crate:

    • Reduced Visual Stimulation: Covering the crate helps reduce visual distractions and external stimuli that might make your puppy feel anxious or restless. This can create a calmer and more relaxing environment for them.
    • Privacy and Security: Just like wild dogs seek out sheltered dens, some puppies feel safer and more secure in a covered crate. The cover provides a sense of privacy and security, which can help reduce stress and anxiety.
    • Better Sleep: Covering the crate can create a dark and cosy space, promoting better sleep for your puppy. It can help establish a sleep-friendly environment for daytime naps and nighttime rest.
    • Temperature Regulation: The cover can also help regulate the temperature inside the crate, making it warmer in colder environments and providing shade in warmer settings.

    However, not all puppies may prefer a covered crate, and individual preferences can vary. Some puppies may feel more comfortable with a partially or fully uncovered crate.

    It's essential to observe your puppy's behaviour and response to the covered crate. If your puppy seems more relaxed and content with the cover, it's a good indication that they enjoy the den-like environment.

    On the other hand, if your puppy appears stressed or uncomfortable with the cover, consider leaving it partially or fully open.

    When covering the crate, ensure proper ventilation to maintain a comfortable temperature for your puppy. Use a breathable and lightweight cover that allows air to circulate freely. Additionally, be mindful of any safety hazards, such as loose fabric or materials that your puppy might chew on.

    Should I play music to soothe my puppy in their crate?

    Soft background music or white noise can help create a calming environment for your puppy during crate time. There are even special playlists designed specifically for dogs to help reduce anxiety.  YouTube and Spotify are a great place to search for calming dog music.

    What is the best age to start crate training to prevent excessive crying?

    The best age to start crate training to prevent excessive crying can vary depending on the individual puppy and their development. In general, it's recommended to begin crate training as early as possible, ideally when the puppy is still young, between 8 to 12 weeks old.

    Starting crate training early allows the puppy to adapt more easily to the concept of being confined and can help prevent excessive crying. Young puppies are generally more adaptable and open to learning new routines, making it easier to establish positive associations with the crate.

    Are there any alternative methods to crate training for a puppy that cries excessively?

    Yes, there are alternative methods to crate training for a puppy that cries excessively or does not seem to respond well to traditional crate training. Not every puppy may adapt to the crate, and it's essential to find a suitable approach that works for your individual puppy's needs and temperament. Here are some alternative methods to consider:

    • Playpen or Puppy-Proofed Area: Instead of using a crate, you can create a puppy-proofed playpen or gated area in a safe and confined space. This allows your puppy some freedom of movement while preventing access to hazardous areas in your home.
    • Tether Training: Tether training involves attaching a leash to your puppy and securing the other end to your waist or a stable object. This allows your puppy to stay near you and prevents them from getting into trouble while still providing some freedom of movement.

    What role does exercise and mental stimulation play in reducing crate crying?

    Exercise and mental stimulation play crucial roles in reducing crate crying and promoting overall well-being in puppies. Providing an appropriate amount of physical activity and mental enrichment can help alleviate restlessness, anxiety, and excessive energy, which can contribute to crate crying. Here's how exercise and mental stimulation can help:

    Physical Exhaustion: Regular exercise, such as walks, playtime, and interactive games, helps burn off excess energy in puppies. A tired puppy is more likely to be calm and content when placed in the crate, reducing the likelihood of crying due to restlessness.

    Mental Stimulation: Mental enrichment activities, such as puzzle toys, training sessions, and interactive play, engage your puppy's mind and prevent boredom. A mentally stimulated puppy is less likely to become anxious or frustrated in the crate.

    Calming Effect: Exercise and mental stimulation release endorphins, which have a calming and stress-reducing effect on dogs. When your puppy is mentally and physically content, they are more likely to feel relaxed in the crate.

    Routine and Predictability: Incorporating regular exercise and mental stimulation into your puppy's daily routine establishes predictability. A consistent routine can help reduce anxiety and create a sense of security, making crate time more manageable.

    Distraction from Separation: Engaging your puppy in stimulating activities before crate time can serve as a distraction from the separation from you, helping them transition more smoothly into the crate.

    Positive Associations: Providing exercise and mental enrichment before crate time can create positive associations with the crate itself. Your puppy may associate the crate with relaxation and downtime after engaging in fun activities.

    Enhanced Sleep Quality: Adequate exercise and mental stimulation can lead to better sleep quality for your puppy. A well-rested puppy is more likely to remain calm and content when confined to the crate.

    It's important to strike a balance and avoid overstimulation before crate time. Providing exercise and mental enrichment in a controlled and structured manner can be more beneficial than allowing your puppy to become overly excited or hyperactive just before crate time.

    Is it possible that my puppy's crate crying is due to a health issue?

    Yes, it is possible that your puppy's crate crying could be due to a health issue. Sometimes, puppies may cry or whine in the crate if they are experiencing physical discomfort or pain. Dogs cannot verbally communicate when they are not feeling well, so crying may be their way of expressing distress.

    Here are some health-related reasons that could cause a puppy to cry in the crate:

    • Urinary or Gastrointestinal Issues: If your puppy is experiencing urinary tract infections, gastrointestinal upset, or other issues, they may cry in the crate as a signal that they need to go to toilet or that something is wrong.
    • Injury or Pain: If your puppy has sustained an injury or is experiencing any kind of physical pain, they may vocalise their discomfort when confined to the crate.
    • Teething: During the teething process, puppies may experience pain and discomfort in their gums, which can lead to increased whining or crying.
    • Respiratory Issues: Puppies with respiratory problems, such as respiratory infections or allergies, may exhibit increased vocalisation due to difficulty breathing or discomfort.
    • General Discomfort: If the crate's bedding or environment is uncomfortable for your puppy, they may cry to communicate their dissatisfaction.

    If you suspect that your puppy's crate crying is related to a health issue, it's essential to consult with a veterinarian. They can perform a thorough examination to identify any potential health problems and recommend appropriate treatment.

    If your puppy's crying is accompanied by other signs of illness, such as lethargy, decreased appetite, vomiting, diarrhoea, or changes in behaviour, seeking veterinary attention promptly is crucial.

    Can I use calming aids or supplements to help my puppy settle in its crate?

    Yes, you can use calming aids or supplements to help your puppy settle in its crate, especially if your puppy experiences anxiety or restlessness during crate time. Calming aids and supplements are designed to help reduce stress and promote relaxation in dogs. 

    However, it's essential to choose products that are safe and appropriate for puppies, as some calming aids may be better suited for adult dogs.

    • Calming Treats: Our Calm & Relaxed calming treats are specifically formulated with natural ingredients like chamomile and lavender which have calming properties. These treats are suitable for puppies aged 8 weeks old.
    • Adaptil/DAP: Adaptil is a synthetic pheromone product that replicates the calming pheromone produced by a mother dog to comfort her puppies. Adaptil comes in the form of diffusers, sprays, and collars and can help puppies feel more secure and relaxed in their crate.
    • Valerian Compound: This Dorwest Herbs supplement is a natural remedy made from herbs and is commonly used to help reduce stress and anxiety in pets. It can be added to your puppy's water or applied directly to their tongue.

    How can I handle nighttime crate crying without disturbing my neighbors?

    Handling nighttime crate crying without disturbing your neighbours requires a thoughtful and gentle approach to help your puppy feel secure and comfortable whilst not causing resentment from your neighbours because of the noise.

    If you're concerned about disturbing your neighbours, consider speaking with them in advance to let them know about your new puppy and the crate training process. Most neighbours will appreciate the courtesy and may be more tolerant and understanding during the adjustment period.

    In summary, crate training can be a challenging process, but by understanding the reasons behind your puppy's crying and implementing effective strategies, you can help them settle in their crate. Addressing separation anxiety, creating positive associations, providing a calming environment, and ensuring proper exercise and mental stimulation are all important factors in helping your puppy feel comfortable and secure in their crate.

    Remember to approach crate training with patience, consistency, and a positive mindset, and seek professional guidance if needed.

    With Wags and Woofs,

    Laura, Dolly & Reggie

    Back to blog